Unpopular opinion: Intuitive eating doesn’t work for everyone
Intuitive eating is often praised for promoting a healthier relationship with food, encouraging people to eat based on their body’s natural hunger and fullness cues. While it works well for some, intuitive eating may not be the best approach for everyone when weight loss is the goal. Here are three key reasons why:
1. Hunger and Fullness Cues Can Be Misleading
For many people, years of dieting, emotional eating, or chaotic eating patterns can disrupt the body's natural hunger and fullness signals. If your hunger cues are off, it’s difficult to rely on them for balanced eating. Stress, hormonal changes, or even medical conditions like insulin resistance can make it harder to tell when you're truly hungry or full, leading to overeating or undereating. In these cases, intuitive eating may not be effective for weight loss because the cues you're supposed to follow aren't reliable.
2. Emotional Eating and Food Cravings May Take Over
Intuitive eating encourages people to honor their hunger and eat what feels right for them. But for individuals who struggle with emotional eating or food cravings, this approach can backfire. If emotions like stress, boredom, or anxiety often lead to eating, relying on intuition may result in consuming excess calories. Similarly, strong cravings for high-calorie foods may override genuine hunger signals, making it difficult to lose weight even if you’re technically following an intuitive approach.
3. Metabolic and Hormonal Factors Can Impact Appetite
For some, factors like menopause, thyroid issues, or metabolic conditions can cause fluctuating appetite levels that don't align with their body's actual energy needs. For instance, some people might feel less hungry even when their body needs more fuel, while others might experience frequent hunger due to insulin resistance or blood sugar imbalances. In these situations, intuitive eating may not help with weight loss because the signals you’re following are influenced by hormonal or metabolic imbalances, not true energy needs.
While intuitive eating can help many develop a healthier relationship with food, it’s not always the right approach for those trying to lose weight, especially when hunger cues are unreliable or emotional and hormonal factors are at play. Be sure to get a plan for YOUR body to have the best weight loss results.
Something NEW at Nutrition with Kels..
A mini masterclass reviewing the TOP reasons for holiday weight gain and what to do to avoid it! Find out how to have the best holiday season yet feeling your best.
